Critical analysis and reviews, Films, Videogames

Ignorance of infrastructure

I don’t want this to be a long post, so I’m going to try and keep it short. But in amongst all the stuff to come tumbling out of events pre and during this year’s E3, especially in regards to the Xbox One, I just feel like companies behind hardware and software for entertainment products are unaware of global access to efficient and fast internet infrastructure, and certainly unaware of the UK situation.

With Don Mattrick declaring, “Fortunately we have a product for people who aren’t able to get some form of connectivity; it’s called Xbox 360,” I feel that he’s completely missing the qualms people have with the Xbox One and its connectivity demands. It’s a device that will need to connect to the internet once during a twenty four hour period and there’s the prospect of developers offloading computation into the cloud. It’s that second one that worries me more.

Now, I’m not talking about Mattrick’s submarine example, which he talks about in the first link, but the far more realistic situation of people on low speed connections (not 56K, but rather ADSL 2 with 2-3Mb/s download) that are also tied to download limits and even FTTC. And it’s definitely the speed situation that’s unlikely to improve in vast parts of the US and certainly in the UK, despite the apparent investment into fibre optic currently happening across Britain.

The fibre conundrum

I can’t game properly online at home now. I am in a FTTC enabled area, but I am so far away from the exchange box that I have struggled to get a straight answer from ISPs and the organisation steering the rollout that I might get a minimum speed on average that is above the top 2Mb/s I currently get and the under 1Mb/s that I often get during peak times (according to the table here, I might get 15Mb/s tops). And it’s during peak times that people, who do have good connections, should also be worried about.

Whether or not UK ISPs have strict traffic control policies has never been extremely easy to determine as it’s often in the small print of their agreements. Some are meant to no longer have them, but if you live in an area that has households who can afford internet connections, an internet enabled device per person in each household… well it’s not hard to imagine that it doesn’t matter what traffic policies ISPs may provide, if the whole street has several people per household streaming video content and/or playing videogames at peak times – a future Xbox One owner could quite easily curse a developer opting for cloud computation.

Of course people without any fibre will be hugely affected by cloud offloading. And this difficult cloud situation will be a really big issue for those in FTTC areas, because that last bit of copper is already hindering them. And it doesn’t look like the FTTH/FTTP situation in the UK is going to catch-up with the rest of the EU or the world any time soon, with the recent announcement by the Fibre to the Home Council Europe that the UK again “failed to qualify” for inclusion in its latest FTTH rankings because less than 1% of households have FTTH. The UK government currently has no real plan for FTTH.

Why care?

But why would Microsoft care about any of this? Well, in the UK, sales of the Xbox 360 are meant to have surpassed 8 million earlier this year. Figures for the whole of the EU looks to be around 24.2 million units sold – this would indicate that the UK makes up a significant proportion of MS’s console market in Europe.

The cloud strategy that Microsoft is pursuing with the Xbox One is truly puzzling at this time. Outside of the EU and parts of Asia and the US, public access to decent connection speeds are even more lacklustre than what I’ve described making the idea of a reliance on cloud an unwelcoming prospect.

Edited 14/06/2013 for clarity over speed designations.


5 thoughts on “Ignorance of infrastructure

  1. I agree. It worries me. I also only get 3 meg ADSL 2.

    My experience of ISPs is that they take 1 to 2 weeks to replace faulty kit. Microsoft’s answer was to use a 3G network card but I can’t get a mobile signal where I live. My 3G comes from a Suresignal box connected to my broadband!

    It is the first time I have seriously started thinking about moving to Sony.

  2. Totally a Real Name says:

    Just wanna point this out, and you’re probably gonna hate me for it, but you mentioned your ISP offers 15MB/s tops on your connection, however their site says 15Mb/s tops. There’s a world of difference there: MB/s=Megabytes per second while Mb/s=Megabits per second. A megabit is an eighth of a megabyte, so 15 megabits would riddle out to just under 2 megabytes per second. By those numbers, your service isn’t actually doing you wrong, now that I think on it.

    Just wanted to bring that to your attention is all.

    • Thanks for pointing that out. I’ve edited for clarity. But that 15Mb/s is a really big might, such is the lack of information about the connection quality from where I live to the box.

  3. JCBDigger says:

    Where it’s important I prefer to write Mbits/s or Mbytes/s to avoid confusion.

    I was looking yesterday at Fibre To The Cabinet (FTTC) and BT’s web site does have some information that states fairly clearly that the distance from the cabinet to your house is a significant limiting factor.

    I’m about 2 miles away from my cabinet and they only quote me 3Mbits/s. I actually get 4Mbits/s so my line quality is better than their estimate based on the distance. FTTC is unlikely to benefit me at all.

    One of the advantages of being in the middle of nowhere is that if everyone on my connection was on at once, I’d probably still only have a contention ratio of 10:1 :-)

    The disadvantage of having so few connections on route is that if I had a poor phone line, perhaps some old aluminium instead of copper, they are unlikely to replace it without considerable pestering.

    • What needs to happen is for a very customer/community centric FTTP provider to emerge who has the ability to say “get lost” to BT and its infrastructure monopoly and then get on with things.

Leave a Reply to Emily King Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.